The Lectionary and the UMC: Avoiding Uzzah

[When you’re done, see my newest post: “The Lectionary and the UMC: The subjects of our verbs.”]

Throughout the history of God’s people, religious renewals have followed a similar pattern. You’ll be unsurprised to know these renewals didn’t begin with a change to policy or structure or a 55-45 vote. Here’s how William J. Abraham describes the Lutheran and Wesleyan renewals, among others:

“They took to immersion in the scriptures, to study of the tradition, to intentional participation in the sacramental life of the church, to prayer, and to extended conversation with their friends.” [note]In his brilliant Waking from Doctrinal Amnesia, p. 91[/note]

As the United Methodist Church faces a time of crisis, I’m convinced that renewal will not come through a vote at our General Conference or the next great policy proposal (not that these are entirely insignificant). It will come the way renewal comes, when we immerse ourselves in the scriptures and prayer and the church’s tradition and sacraments––and when we have extended conversation with each other concerning these practices and shaped by them.

To be sure, we can’t undertake these practices for the sake of proving ourselves correct. We do it to seek a word from God. Or perhaps better, to stop making ourselves the subjects of all our verbs and instead to say, “Speak, Lord, for your servants are listening.”

Whether you are United Methodist or not, might we ask how God speaks to us––not just as individuals, but as communities of people, even denominations––through his scriptures? What if we immersed ourselves in the scriptures according to our own lectionary? Does God have a word we can hear together here?

Avoiding Uzzah

The Old Testament lectionary passage for this week (2 Samuel 6:1-5, 12b-19) is as remarkable for what it leaves out as for what it contains. The passage narrates the arrival of the ark of God in Jerusalem. It leaves out Uzzah’s sudden death.

Verses 6-7, missing from our prescribed lectionary reading:

“When they came to the threshing floor of Nakon, Uzzah reached out and took hold of the ark of God, because the oxen stumbled. Yahweh’s anger burned against Uzzah because of his irreverent act; therefore God struck him down, and he died there beside the ark of God.”

The lectionary frequently leaves out portions of passages. Sometimes that’s for the sake of brevity, other times for the sake of focus on one particular aspect of the passage. In this case, though, I suspect it’s to avoid having to deal with what happened to Uzzah. This makes sense to me. I’d probably prefer to avoid it. But an honest immersion in the scriptures doesn’t let us off that easily.

Why are we uncomfortable with the Uzzah passage? It seems like the wrong answer to a common question: “Would a loving God really do that?” How could a loving and compassionate God strike someone down? And for this?

Richard Dawkins loves texts like this. He uses them as basis for a central claim in The God Delusion: “The God of the Old Testament is arguably the most unpleasant character in all fiction: jealous and proud of it; a petty, unjust, unforgiving control-freak…” [note]p. 51. That sentence keeps going for quite a while longer.[/note] Uzzah tries to steady the ark on the cart and God strikes him dead. Uzzah’s (ultimate) punishment does not seem to fit his (very minor) crime.

Uzzah’s demise traces back to Numbers 4:15: “After Aaron and his sons have finished covering the holy furnishings and all the holy articles, and when the camp is ready to move, only then are the Kohathites to come and do the carrying. But they must not touch the holy things or they will die. The Kohathites are to carry those things that are in the tent of meeting.”

The ark of God––the throne of God on earth among the Israelites––was intended to be carried like this.

Picture courtesy of bibleencyclopedia.com

Does that look familiar?

Looks kind of like this.

Picture courtesy of paranormalromantics.blogspot.com

A royal procession for a King.

Instead, the Israelites chose to move the ark of Yahweh as if it were luggage, loaded onto an oxcart.

Courtesy of http://www.sgeorgiastreet.church

Uzzah’s decision to reach out and touch the ark, disregarding God’s command and God’s holiness, was far from the first act of irreverence on the part of the Israelites. But it was the action that resulted in Yahweh’s wrath finally breaking out.

When we ask whether a loving and compassionate God would strike Uzzah dead, our hearts want to say no. But God did strike Uzzah dead, and while our lectionary can avoid it, we cannot.

Essential but not Sufficient

God’s compassion is an essential part of understanding the nature of God. But God’s compassion alone is not sufficient for understanding God. We make a great mistake when we confuse essential for sufficient.

Along with recognizing God’s compassion, we must recognize what the Israelites here ignored: God’s holiness. They had been told to fear Yahweh, to walk in obedience to him and observe his commands and decrees. This, too, was an essential part of their understanding and knowing God. Uzzah’s death was a result of their lack of fear and obedience.

When we avoid Uzzah to focus on a God of compassion, we don’t get a better God, we get a false god––one of our own making.

We could also do the opposite––to fixate on the God who strikes Uzzah dead. This is how Richard Dawkins would prefer it. But that overlooks the God who mercifully returns to be Israel’s God––visible in the ark’s procession to Jerusalem––even after their repeated rejections and rebellions. If we did this, we would likewise be worshiping a god of our own making, one who desires sacrifice, not mercy.

The Lectionary and the UMC

There are two common watchwords right now in the UMC: compassion and orthodoxy. Both are essential to the Christian faith. Neither is sufficient.

Compassion tells us to listen to those on the margins, the minorities, the least of these. Orthodoxy tells us to listen to those who’ve gone before us. Who should we listen to? Both!

Compassion tells us we should give special attention to care for the marginalized and oppressed, whatever the cost. Orthodoxy tells us we should give special attention to reverent obedience to God’s word and the church’s historic teaching, whatever the cost. Which should we tend to? Both!

Compassion tells us we should be wary of injustice. Orthodoxy tells us we should be wary of heresy. Which should we be wary of? Both!

Our problems come when we take either of these not just as essential, but as a sufficient rule for our faith and life, and thereby nullify the other.

If I find myself regularly citing those on the margins, I may need to spend extra time listening to those who’ve gone before us (and not just those who say what I want to hear). If I find myself regularly citing those who’ve gone before us, I may need to spend extra time listening to those on the margins (and not just those who say what I want to hear).

Our church cannot avoid Uzzah. God is a holy God. His eyes are too pure to look on evil; he cannot tolerate wrongdoing.[note]From Hab 1:13[/note] Neither can our church fixate on Uzzah. His death shows us only part of God’s nature. Yahweh is still a compassionate and gracious God, slow to anger, abounding in love.[note]Found throughout the OT. See, e.g. Ps 103:8; Jonah 4:2[/note]

Like it? Or just want to discuss it more? I’d be honored if you’d share it –– use the social media links at left. Or send me an email for follow-up discussion. Or if you haven’t already, click here to subscribe for more. Thank you!

[When you’re done, see my newest post: “The Lectionary and the UMC: The subjects of our verbs.”]

Evangelical Activism (pt. I): From abolition to abortion

What do you think of when you think of evangelicals?

Almost none of us think of the group Donald Dayton describes. He tells of 19th century evangelicals who were “heavily involved in the abolition of slavery, fighting for the poor, and women’s rights.”

“Evangelical revivals called people not only to personal atonement but to putting faith into action. At their ‘altar calls’ people would come to Christ and immediately sign up for the anti-slavery campaign!”[note]That’s Jim Wallis’s summary of Dayton’s book in the foreword to Rediscovering an Evangelical Heritage.[/note]

You probably don’t associate evangelical with these great social justice causes, do you? Of the people I know, those who would identify as strong advocates for social justice would be the least inclined to identify as evangelical. But Dayton paints this picture of activist evangelicalism in Rediscovering an Evangelical Heritage (I highly recommend it).

Above all, he depicts them as devoted abolitionists. Others at the time may have considered them rabid abolitionists –– abolition-at-all-costs abolitionists.[note]Jonathan Blanchard, founder of Wheaton College –– “the Harvard of evangelicalism” –– is a good example of one of those radical abolitionists. He called slave-holding “not a solitary, but a social sin” and would not tolerate advocacy for anything less than quick and total abolition.[/note] They constituted a sizable voting bloc, with heavy support for and leadership in the Liberty Party––a party devoted above all else to abolishing slavery.

How closely aligned were the Liberty Party and evangelicalism? Dayton says “the party functioned almost like an evangelical institution in which antislavery votes served as evidence of sanctified living […] An antislavery ballot provided proof of a person’s unqualified allegiance to God.“[note]pp. 131-132, emphasis mine[/note]

If Dayton’s picture is accurate, those 19th century evangelicals were one-issue voters. I wonder if I would have been (acknowledging the impossibility of that hypothetical). Was this one issue so important that any like-minded politician would be considered an ally and everyone else a foe, regardless of all the rest? Living in the early 19th century, could I have ever voted for a politician who would not advance the cause of abolition?

Another definition of evangelicalism names activism as one of its four distinctive marks.[note]See David W. Bebbington’s The Dominance of Evangelicalism. This activism includes both evangelism and social work. “[S]ocial work that carried over into pressure for reform was equally characteristic for this period,” he writes (p. 38).[/note] Evangelicals are, by nature, activists, pushing for reform. The U.S. has never seen such an important cause for activism as slavery. And so the cause united evangelicals politically like few others could.

Evangelicals and activism today

For the past half-century, the large majority of those who identify as evangelical have again united around one political cause: the cause to abolish abortion.

If you don’t like that statement, stick with me.

[If you have have had an abortion, assisted, or insisted in one, a much better starting place: “A pastor’s note to women who have had abortions––and to those who assisted or insisted.”]

Abortion is a complicated and nuanced issue. Anyone treating it as black-and-white hasn’t had enough honest conversations or sought out enough information.[note]Though we treat it as clear-cut in retrospect, the abolition debate also dealt with many nuances. To the point that Abraham Lincoln’s stance opposed the kind of quick abolition those early evangelicals called for. It could be catastrophic to the lives and futures of many slave-owners and slaves alike. He wrote, “the promulgation of abolition doctrines tends rather to increase than abate its evils.” (see Collected Works of Abraham Lincoln, volume 1, p. 75.) This isn’t to equate the two. After the abolition of slavery, there would now be no nuance in a debate about reinstituting it. If abortion were entirely abolished, we would forever face the complexities that would come with that decision.[/note] Many pro-life evangelicals recognize those nuances and know they require compassion and careful thought. We would benefit from more pro-life evangelicals recognizing these nuances.

The vast majority of those who call themselves evangelical agree on this: The abortion statistics in the U.S. are tragic. Of the more than 600,000 abortions likely to take place in the U.S. this year, less than 8% are likely to be because of rape, incest, or health concerns. Many in the pro-life cause would like to consider how abortion can remain safe and legal in those rare cases.

From a 2004 Guttmacher Institute survey, shared on http://abort73.com/abortion_facts/us_abortion_statistics/

For the other cases––whether you agree with them or not, most evangelicals hear “can’t afford a baby” as a reason for abortion the same way abolitionists heard “can’t afford to lose my slaves” as a reason to keep the institution of slavery. It is a significant concern––and at our best, one that we rally to support someone through––but not a reason to take a life.

For American evangelicals, the pro-life cause over the past 50 years may have been the most galvanizing political issue since slavery. (Aside: We have plenty of reason to ask why this would be the case. Why not anti-lynching campaigns or other civil rights causes? That the American Church did not speak with one voice on these issues is a tragic failure.)

Many evangelicals are likely to say they could never cast a vote for someone who will not fight for the ~540,000 unborn children who will be aborted this year when rape, incest, the health of the mother, and other extreme cases, are not at root. Though they see many other tragedies in the world, this is the one that has caught their attention and seems to them the worst.

For all the rhetoric about abortion being legal, healthy, and rare, many are heartbroken and appalled that abortion is currently the leading cause of death in the United States.[note]It just edges out heart disease and cancer. You usually won’t see it listed this way, since most people reporting these statistics don’t consider abortion a “cause of death.”[/note] Abortion in the U.S. is not rare.

So for many evangelicals, I wonder if an anti-abortion vote today would be similar to an anti-slavery vote in the 1800s: evidence of sanctified living, proof of a person’s unqualified allegiance to God, an attempt to set at right the most wrong of all wrongs in our society today.[note]”Most wrong of all wrongs” as they perceive it. I’m not making the absolute claim that abortion is, in fact, the “most wrong of all wrongs” today. But I think we can make a strong case for it.[/note] For many evangelicals, I wonder if the connection between faith and this one issue is just as strong––hard to imagine that any real Christian could support a politician on the other side of this issue. (To be clear: This is not my position. Just as I also don’t hold the position that no real Christian could possibly vote for Trump.)

At a conference earlier this year, I attended several sessions on the state of evangelicalism. At least among this group, there were no #MAGA celebrations going on. These crowds were generally aghast about our President’s contempt toward people who weren’t born in the U.S. or Western Europe. (I think it was the week of his “shithole countries” comment.) But also in every one of those sessions, someone from the audience asked, “But what do we do about abortion?” It wasn’t a rally cry to the GOP. It was a morally conflicted question. These people couldn’t imagine voting for someone whose Supreme Court nominees would uphold more progressive standards regarding abortion––not just preserving the status quo, but likely to advance a more progressive standard––and for decades.[note]For instance, if Antonin Scalia and Anthony Kennedy had been replaced by more progressive judges, the Court would be expected to rule against pro-life pregnancy crisis centers that do not want to be required to post notices about state programs providing free or low-cost abortions.[/note]

The evangelical position here is no deluded extremist position. People like Ross Douthat––a columnist for the New York Times, a #NeverTrumper and ongoing Trump critic… hardly a FOX News contributor––have called for “judicial action, not restraint [in] Overturning our inhumane abortion settlement.” I don’t know that Douthat could be identified as an evangelical (he’s Roman Catholic), but he names the position held by many evangelicals. They want to see change to how our country views and uses abortion. For many, it’s enough to make any like-minded politician an ally and all others foes.

You may or may not agree with this stance on abortion. You should know it is there. If you disagree because of the nuance and complexity of the situation, that is understandable. Not that we can simply shrug at inhumane practices because they’re nuanced and complex. (See also: current immigration and refugee crises.) If you disagree because you don’t find abortion to be that morally problematic, I admit I don’t understand you at all. I’d love to know more. If you disagree because you say, “But what about [insert other issue]?”… let’s talk about that. Next week.

This is part I. Part II: “How evangelicals became Republicans, and the dangers of good activism” will post next week. To be sure you don’t miss it, click here to subscribe.

Failure of Nerve

About a decade ago, our church leadership team read Simple Church together. In principle, we all bought into the book’s premise: Identify the few things that matter most; do those things; do only those things.

As we read and worked, our team got excited about the great change that was coming. We could see how this kind of simplicity and focus was going to improve everything. So we identified the few things that mattered most for us––worship, growth in small groups, and service.[note]When I see the hundreds (thousands?) of churches with similar banners, I wonder if they all read Simple Church.[/note] We resolved to focus all of our energy and publicity and resources on those things.

People would get tired of hearing an invitation into our small groups because that invitation would be so constant. Our bulletin would change––rather than thirty announcements to get lost in, there would be only three. Our budget would change––rather than hundreds of line items fracturing our resources, we would focus all of our resources on these few things. We were all excited about it, in principle.

And then we had to start talking about all the other things.

Those items that would no longer be in the announcements. (Remember? We’re simplifying the announcements to talk about small groups ad nauseam.)

Those line items that would no longer be in the budget. (Remember? We’re reallocating our resources to focus them all on worship, grow, and serve. So much extra money for the most important things!)

This was when it all began to fall apart. “But the softball team…!” “But that fellowship dinner…!” As we went down the list of items we would no longer fund in the budget or advertise in the bulletin, it turned out each of them was important to someone. We were supposed to identify the few things that mattered most and do only those things. But everything we were doing mattered.

So what about our exciting new simple church? We decided we could at least organize the announcements according to our new slogan. And we could organize the budget the same way. If it didn’t fit under “worship,” “grow,” or “serve,” it would be an indication that we shouldn’t be doing it.

You know what happened then. We discovered that everything we were doing could be shoehorned into one of those categories. The bulletin announcements remained the same, but they had new headings. Same for the budget line items. We resolved to tweak some of those items––ask how the softball team could be a bit more of a spiritual growth opportunity, etc.––though I’m not sure how long that resolve lasted.

After several months of reading and planning and excitement, we had a new, Simple Church-approved slogan. And the same church.

Why real change fails

Why did our change effort result in a few months of dreaming, a new slogan, and no real change? For the same reason that most real change fails. Change inherently involves loss. And loss involves pain. And once we finally realize the changes we’re planning will involve pain, we have a failure of nerve and try to minimize the pain.

The best way to minimize the pain:
1 – Tweak the old system (to avoid the pain of real change)
2 – Tell yourselves you’re following the new plan (to avoid the pain of wasted time planning)

A more detailed version of that failure of nerve pattern:

 

In his book on the same subject[note]My diagram and definition of failure of nerve are my own. I’m not sure whether Edwin Friedman would approve or not.[/note] Edwin Friedman says it like this:

“[W]hat is clear about pain universally is this: To the extent that we are motivated to get on with life, we seem to be able to tolerate more pain; in other words, our threshold seems to increase. Conversely, to the extent that we are unmotivated to get out of our chair, our threshold seems to go down.”[note]in A Failure of Nerve, p. 93[/note]

Unless we’re motivated enough, we will not make fundamental change.[note]Ironically, Friedman talks about being unmotivated to get out of our chair while much of the United Methodist Church is relying on a process that requires us to make our most important decisions while we sit in the same chair for 8 hours.[/note] We’ll make tweaks and call it change. And sadly, stagnant and declining organizations usually don’t get motivated enough until crisis. And they don’t usually realize they’re in crisis until too late.

The first post I ever wrote here was about an experience like this. The Bishop had called for a task force to reconsider how we were funding our campus ministries. They consumed 8% of the Conference budget at the time. They were under fire for producing too little return on the Conference’s significant investment. Not that they were all failing. There were many good stories and important ministries happening. But there were others that couldn’t name more than ten students involved in their ministries. Since those ministries were receiving $70,000 from the Conference, they were good candidates for the “most expensive small group” award.[note]Thanks to Adam Sparks for this excellent award title.[/note]

Nevertheless, many leaders were unprepared to face our realities and endure the pain of fundamental change. Instead, our Conference passed a tweak to the system. I didn’t yet have the language for this, but now I can name it as a failure of nerve. We knew we needed to make a change (lots of talk around the Conference about under-performance and major investment; the Bishop had called for a task force!) But we weren’t willing to do it. Those leaders didn’t yet realize their crisis.

A few years later, the campus ministries lost their Conference funding. That task force had been the last chance at preserving their funding.

(A point of celebration: that new funding crisis forced our campus ministries to “get out of their chairs.” Some that were struggling before are thriving now.)

Who will hold the line?

Is fundamental change needed where you are? If so, are you willing to pay the price? There will be loss––and pain.

For any group to pay that price, it will require a bold leader who is prepared to hold the line when others start saying, “But what about [insert pain point]??”

What does that bold leader look like? Especially in church world, they often look like a jerk. I wonder if this is why we so rarely do it. Edwin Friedman describes them this way: “Anyone who wishes to advance our species or an institution must possess those qualities which those who have little sense of self will perceive as narcissistic. All this besides the fact that ‘arrogant,’ ‘headstrong,’ ‘narcissistic,’ and ‘cold’ will be the terms used against any person who tries to be more himself or herself.”[note]p. 190[/note]

Arrogant, headstrong, narcissistic, and cold… Church world rejects these (perceived) characteristics perhaps more than any other world. Do we have room for leaders who are willing to hold the line? Or will we reject them as cold, arrogant, and lacking compassion?

I wonder if the church’s penchant for compassion may lead us to a more regular failure of nerve than most others. Of course, this is often only a perceived compassion, more properly called a desire to keep everyone happy, which is often at its heart narcissistic.